This week we got to watch the film The Others staring Nicole Kidman for our RIG Horror class. Confession time: This is not the first time I have seen this
film. I have seen it a lot. I actually saw it on it’s opening night. I had a
friend who’s favorite actor (Nicole Kidman) in it so I could get her to go with
me to a scary film. Normally she’s a Rom Com kind of girl. So I jumped at the
chance to get to see this one with her. Anyway I was really glad that I did
because I loved the movie. The twist ending was probably my favorite part (more
on that later). But anyway I ended up buying the movie when it hit Blu-ray and
I've watched it a bunch since then. But to make sure I remembered it accurately
I watched it again last night so I could give a thorough once over for you
guys.
What I Liked:
Gothic Nature of The Film:
So it’s no secret I am a freak for all things Gothic. I love
it and this movie is Gothic as hell. Lush setting, isolated decrepit mansion,
fog, three low graves by a Tim Burton-esque dead tree, the twist ending,
intruders, ghosts, the self playing piano, mystery, intrigue, and so much more.
Every Gothic detail imaginable was attended to. And visually it made this movie
very rich and detailed for me.
As Gothic as it gets. Fog (check), Foreboding house in the background (check), heavy sigh (check).
Hints All The Way Through:
I love how there are hints the whole way through the film of
what the twist ending is. In fact one of the first times we see the character
Mr. Tuttle he says “I imagine he’s dead like all the rest” (Amenábar) as he approaches the house. If that's not premonition I guess I must not know what is. It’s not the only time we get that
kind of glimpse but it’s so subtle that you may not even notice unless you are
watching it for the 20th time and you’re a total nerd like myself. But they are
there for those of us so inclined to look for them.
I also liked how the children knew what had happened from
the beginning. Well at least Anne did. But immediately her view point is
discounted because it doesn't mesh with the mothers view point. I love that the
kids are the smart ones and they know what is going on but no one will believe
them including their own mother. The mother doesn't even entertain the idea
that the children could be right. She just shuts it down as nonsense. One of the
first scenes we get of the children, we have Anne say emphatically “It did
happen,” (Amenábar) and she is soundly
put down. Mom’s denial is stronger than the children’s understanding. That
understanding being a major theme throughout the rest of the film.
How's that for discounting the children's POV.
Imagery:
I love the use of curtains as a metaphor in this film.
Usually that sort of metaphor is reserved for books not film. I love how they
serve a dual purpose of keeping the light out and metaphorically for keeping
the truth out. When the curtains are intact the characters are in denial. When they
have been remove then the truth comes out. I love, love, love that this detail
was put in there. It’s subtle yet meaningful.
The Ending:
Usually I am not surprised by the ending of movies. I tend
to see them coming a mile away. But the first time I saw this film I had no
idea what was coming. It’s so masterfully crafted that on first watch I had no
idea how it would end.
What I Didn't Like:
So again I had to find something I hated in a movie I loved
and the only thing I could come up with is this:
The Husband Coming Back:
I really don’t understand the reasoning for the appearance
of the husband. It seems really out of place in the story. He just sort of
meanders in and then meanders back out. For me I don’t see the point. It seems
like it could have been cut and the plot would have been fine. He doesn't
really do anything, nor does he move the plot forward for me. He almost seems
like a way to elongate the story rather than improve it. For me all the husband
scenes could be cut and it would be just fine. Maybe someone else can figure
out why he’s even in there. Because I couldn't figure it out.
Final Thoughts:
Over all I really enjoy this film. I have very little
negative things to say about it. It’s a good film and the twist ending is very
earned.
Works
Cited
The Others.
Dir. Alejandro Amenábar. Perf. Nicole Kidman. 2001. Blu-ray.
